The Great Burrito Extortion Case received generally positive reviews from critics, with many praising the band's ability to craft catchy, humorous songs. The album has since become a fan favorite, and its influence can be seen in later pop-punk bands. Bowling for Soup's use of satire and social commentary has also inspired a new generation of musicians to experiment with similar themes.
The album debuted at and received mixed-to-positive reviews from critics who either embraced the goofy charm or felt the humor was becoming dated.