Musannaf — Ibn Abi Shaybah 37157

For the average Muslim seeking to understand the ruling on water and impurity: The ruling is sound—water of 540 liters or more remains pure unless its properties change. But rely for proof on Sunan al-Tirmidhi 67 or Sunan Abi Dawud 63 , not solely on Musannaf 37157 .

A Kufan narrator who is generally classified as Saduq (truthful), though some critics noted occasional errors in his individual narrations. He is a primary source for traditions coming from Sa'id ibn Jumhan.

"'Amr ibn al-'As said: 'By Allah, if Abu Bakr and 'Umar left this wealth [of the state] while some of it was permissible for them, then they were truly deluded and deficient in judgment. But I swear by Allah that they were neither deluded nor deficient! And if they were two men for whom this wealth [that we have acquired after them] was forbidden, then we are surely ruined. By Allah, the delusion is on our part.'" musannaf ibn abi shaybah 37157

Let us locate the reference precisely.

Because different modern publishers use different numbering systems, "37157" may refer to one of several distinct narrations depending on the edition (e.g., the Al-Hut , Shathri , or Awamah editions). Most Common Narrations for Number 37157 For the average Muslim seeking to understand the

The specific hadith number is particularly fascinating. In several established editions and database systems, this number actually corresponds to two distinct narrations , one following the other. This dual structure is not an accident; it is a deliberate editorial choice by the author, creating a powerful dialogue by placing two reports on a related theme side-by-side. They work in concert, rather than in contradiction.

Unlike the "Six Books" (Sihah Sittah), Ibn Abi Shaybah compiled narrations regardless of their individual authenticity, leaving the critical evaluation to researchers. grading of this specific chain or more reports from this chapter on the Caliphate? He is a primary source for traditions coming

Umar warned Fatimah that if Ali, Zubayr, and others continued meeting in her home to oppose Abu Bakr's caliphate, he would set the house on fire. Following this threat, the group left to give their allegiance. Historical & Theological Context